Hope this helps someone and save you the countless hours I spent if the previous tips don't do it for you either:
After a last ditch, desperation attempt at a new install I finally am able to log in. I basically had to go into the db backup and remove everything that wasn't related to the content and that seemed to do whatever needed to be done.
OR
I also removed a few squirrley addons like fblogin (that never seemed to install correctly, and eIRTE rich text addon beta *cough* that was the last addon I installed.
Still not sure exactly what did it, but I was in hammer mode and took out everything that could be it and now I am back up. For reference for those that want to try this method the tables I restored were:
Content Tables
If you used the default setting on the install your db_prefix is probably "modx". Otherwise it's whatever prefix you defined during install.
[li]{db-prefix}_categories_closure[/li]
[li]{db-prefix}_dashboard_widget
(only because I had Big Brother Addon which installs a manager widget. If you have no custom widgets you probably won't need to restore this.)[/li]
[li]{db-prefix}_dashboard_widget_placement
(same as above)[/li]
[li]{db-prefix}_documentgroup_names[/li]
[li]{db-prefix}_element_property_sets[/li]
[li]{db-prefix}_menus[/li]
[li]{db-prefix}_property_set[/li]
[li]{db-prefix}_site_content[/li]
[li]{db-prefix}_site_htmlsnippets[/li]
[li]{db-prefix}_site_snippets[/li]
[li]{db-prefix}_site_templates[/li]
[li]{db-prefix}_site_tmplvars[/li]
[li]{db-prefix}_site_tmplvar_contentvalues[/li]
[li]{db-prefix}_site_tmplvar_templates[/li]
Addon Stuff Only if you Have These Installed
Note here is that you need to compare at your db dump to a clean install with no addons to determine what tables your addons have create in your db.
Gallery Addon Tables
[li]{db-prefix}_gallery_albums[/li]
[li]{db-prefix}_gallery_album_contexts[/li]
[li]{db-prefix}_gallery_album_items[/li]
[li]{db-prefix}_gallery_items[/li]
[li]{db-prefix}_gallery_tags[/li]
Quip Addon Tables
[li]{db-prefix}_quip_comments[/li]
[li]{db-prefix}_quip_comments_closure[/li]
[li]{db-prefix}_quip_comment_notify[/li]
[li]{db-prefix}_quip_threads[/li]
Redirect Addon Tables
[li]{db-prefix}_redirects[/li]
Register(Login) Addon Tables ( I think... if you have them save them.)
[li]{db-prefix}_register_queues[/li]
[li]{db-prefix}_register_topics[/li]
This required a fresh install and manual installation of all addons, then the clear cache, flush sessions, restore the db tables above, reinstall (upgrade) and viola.
Note: I backed up the newly installed db before I attempted the import so I could revert to it if the import didn't work this time. Of course the one time I though to do it I didn't need it:)
This method is not for the faint hearted and probably only for the desperate like I was that had little to lose and some db experience. Of course if anyone smarter than me would care to correct, expand, or clarify, I'm sure it would be useful.