Thanks Jul, I’ve ended up giving up altogether on treasure chest
looks like that system was not set up to handle multiple prices for one product, which is what I was getting at. So I dropped the cart altogether for now and each item takes you directly to PayPal. I’ve added some snippet to customize the BuyNow choices directly from MODx rather than haing to generate them through PayPal
Looks like I need to use size1-10.00|size2-11.00|size3-12.00 which is a bit harder on the end user, but being over budget is it is it’ll have to work