We launched new forums in March 2019—join us there. In a hurry for help with your website? Get Help Now!
    • 26457
    • 1 Posts
    Hi everyone,
    I am planning on writing a small community portal solution for a small user group. Apart from a few standard functions (extendable user profiles, avatars, chatroom, discussion forum, wiki, role-based user management, internationalization, security, authentication, fully skinnable UI so that all modules look alike after editing a central design template...) I also want to add one custom specific module providing a custom specific function.
    So we are talking about a normal web portal solution with lots of standard functionality and little custom functions.

    So my idea was this:
    1. Find a suitable, existing web portal / web framework / CMS
    2. Install all standard modules I need
    3. Create a central design template
    4. Write my custom module
    5. Be happy with a finished portal with a minimum of custom code writing (= fast).
    6. Extend it whereever I need to

    Here’s my question:
    What should I use? Zope/Plone or some PHP-portal/CMS/framework or something else?

    Even though I am a Java developer, I know doing the above thing J2EE-style would take too long.
    I don’t know PHP nor Python but I assume this project is worth learning a new language.

    But which one? What do you suggest? Why?
    If you suggest PHP: which framework / portal / CMS is suitable for my project?

    Of course you will say: use MODx. But why? What makes it my #1 choice for this project? Or is it? What alternatives should I consider?

    Thanks

    scrut

      • 27376
      • 576 Posts
      MODx does not have / has poor implementations of: wiki, chatroom, forum, user management.

      For the forums though you can use the SMF bridge with MODx. SMF is the forum application you’re reading this on smiley

      Good luck with your decision!