G’day,
I find it strange because the framework for all of it seems to be in place.
Anyway, I deployed ModX on my test servers last night and lost all the graphics links etc. and I thought to myself, I don’t need to go off on another week of fixing installation issues with another CSS so I’m gonna wander back to etomite (which I have working sweet as a nut (after many hours of fixing the aformentioned issues)).
The thing that attracted me to ModX was the user registration but I manage and create professional business sites and I stopped myself and asked the question "when was the last time we needed a user area?" to which the question was "never" so I shrugged and crossed that one off the list.
I loved the idea of front-end editing but it just stopped working on our servers (tried three different ISPs all with varying PHP and MySQL version with my main server being the latest) and once again, what the heck, if you can’t lock the users out of the back end, why bother given we can conditionally limit user access in the back-end anyway.
So, the similarities are so absolute between these two FINE products, I might as well stay with the one I have ironed the issues out of.
I have written a member’s area front-end manager myself that works so I have all the web user functionality I want.
The account create might be a good idea but it is not worth the time required to get to the bottom of it.
This is by no means a slight on ModX.
If I had have found it first I would have burnt the candle on this one, but its time to settle on one and, as Lord Nelson so famously said "No time for maneuvering, go straight at ’em".
So, Etomite it is and, who knows, perhaps I will write my own user account creation if I can be bothered developing code in a development environment that takes me back to the good old days of Fortran and Edlin
(who knows, perhaps one day someone will develop a stand alone symbolic debugger for PHP (something I have had for C++ and Delphi for 14 years)).
Anyway I will keep ModX on the radar and look forward to the issues I mentioned above being fixed and may revisit it. A great product and I would love it to provide the functionality it promised.