We launched new forums in March 2019—join us there. In a hurry for help with your website? Get Help Now!
    • 28508
    • 73 Posts
    Hello,

    since I updated Quip to 1.2.4, many comments are automatically deleted somehow.
    I undeleted them, but the next day, they were deleted again.
    Unfortunately, I can’t see any logical structure behind it, there are always different comments affected.

    I don’t think Quip is buggy now with that update, but I also can’t think of any mistake I might have made.
    Does anyone have a hint for me?

    Thanks in advance,

    stetus

    I use MODx 2.0.6 advanced (but will update within the next days to 2.0.7).
      • 28508
      • 73 Posts
      Update:

      Actually I’m receiving a lot of spam, altough captcha is enabled, but the spam is deleted automatically by quip (I can’t remember if I specified this in the settings during the installation, I can’t find anything in the System Settings).
      Could it be that there is a connection, maybe the whole thread is getting deleted by quip, when a spam-comment is posted?

      Thank you,
      stetus
        • 3932
        • 19 Posts
        I have the same problems.
        In my case I don’t receive many comments to my blog posts or any kind of spam. But sometimes comments disappear from web pages. After looking into DB I found out that "deleted" field has value 1. Setting it to 0 helps, but after some time they are deleted again.
          • 10257
          • 55 Posts
          Problem is, that somehow a crawler stumples upon the "delete post" links in the frontend, that shouldn’t be displayed in the first place. Only solution is, to actually disable the frontend delete processing.

          I wrote about this in this post

          BTW: I wonder why the "mark as spam" links aren’t crawled...
            • 28508
            • 73 Posts
            Thanks a lot for your answer,
            it seems as that would have been the problem.

            Thank you!
              • 28508
              • 73 Posts
              Cheered too soon :’(...

              There is no "delete-post" in the frontend anymore, comments are still being deleted automatically.
              I also still can’t see why some of the comments are deleted and others not...

              Am I the only one having this problem? I really can’t imagine how to fix that up, it’s strange.

              Thank you,
              stetus
                • 3932
                • 19 Posts
                Quote from: stetus at Jan 31, 2011, 02:50 PM

                ...

                There is no "delete-post" in the frontend anymore, comments are still being deleted automatically.
                I also still can’t see why some of the comments are deleted and others not...

                Am I the only one having this problem? I really can’t imagine how to fix that up, it’s strange.

                ...

                I have the same problem too. I wrote about this above. Didn’t found any solution and still have to manually set value of "deleted" property to 0.
                  • 24400
                  • 0 Posts
                  Long time reader, first time poster.

                  I’m also having the same issue with comments deleting themselves. I have trawled through server logs to find a trigger but no luck, I assume it’s a spambot activating ’delete’/’report as spam’ links in the front end, as suggested earlier (though perhaps I flatter myself presuming my site receives the attention of spambots).

                  I’ve disabled Remove and ReportAsSpam, and will see if this resolves it. Might be worth noting that I’ve used an empty string to counter the default true(1) value in each case since false(0) returns a ’0’ string into the front end. Works the same in all the tests I have run as logged in or anonymous user, but if this doesn’t work I’ll try an explicit false(0) value to be sure.

                  My quip call is below:

                  [[!Quip? &thread=`[[+pagetitle]]` 
                  &allowRemove=``
                  &allowReportAsSpam=`` 
                  &closeAfter=`0`
                  &gravatarIcon=`monsterid` 
                  &gravatarSize=`80` 
                  &idPrefix=`com[[+id]]`
                  ]]


                  I have a question, Quip appears to automatically manage comments with a time sensitive trigger for a few of it’s features, which I thought may be related.
                  Firstly, there is the default allowRemove within 3 minutes of posting (for the author of the comment only) before disabling the remove. However, I have found this remove feature remains past the 3 minutes and is available to all users - hence the above actions.
                  Secondly, there is a default 14 day close thread action (which I have also deactivated above), but this would not seem relavant as my comments appear to be removed after 24-36 hours.

                  Now for the question - are there any other automated comment management features that could be active. While the Quip documentation is sufficient for basic setup, it doesn’t help explain some of these subtleties.

                  I would greatly appreciate any response to the above question, but also if you have a more appropriate method of identifying the issue I would be happy to hear that too.

                  Many thanks.

                  P.S. I love you work.