Overall this looks good! Congrats!
I’m guessing you’re going to fix the image dimensions on the front page... it looks stretched.
On your contact page, I’d recommend using the Hiveware Enkoder to encrypt your email addresses so they don’t get picked up by spammers/harvesters:
http://hivelogic.com/enkoder
this applies to the email address in the footer as well.
On that page you may also want to avoid spacing the contact #’s so widely... it looks like you have 2 line breaks when you could probably use just one for easier reading.
More importantly, it looks like your CAPTCHA code isn’t being generated correctly. This is often due to the web server not having the correct PHP libraries installed (GD and FreeType).
Lesser things: you probably don’t need to pop a new window when someone clicks on the masstimes.org or "School Website" links... personally, I find that sort of window popping to be obnoxious because people know how to use the back button or open links in a new tab without you doing it for them.
You have a broken link for your privacy policy. Looks like maybe you put in something like
href="http://www.saintmonicaconverse.net/[~54~]"
Instead of