yes
I agree that the code is not perfect, and my example was , just that, an example...However, I do agree that SMFs inline editing is a better way. My point is that using the quickedit tool doesn’t really give a good "overall image" of what the content look like on the page.
And yes, newspublisher is usably, but me, and my company, has around 2000 pages of news, and while modx certainly handles it ok, it isn’t easy to maintain (the directory tree is VERY long! and publishing news is not so easy either because one must heavely change the code (which I have done) to do what almost any cms/cmf/ems have, A good newssystem. I know that modx isn’t a cms and I don’t want it to be just a cms either, I just want do have some more development on the newsside