We launched new forums in March 2019—join us there. In a hurry for help with your website? Get Help Now!
    • 3781
    • 24 Posts
    I developed a Flash website that pulls in XML generated by MODx/Ditto. I’m no SEO expert, but I know Flash and SEO aren’t very good friends. So seeing as the content is in MODx I can generate dynamic google friendly and searchable pages (using the tips and links ive found in this thread: http://modxcms.com/forums/index.php/topic,28860.0.html )

    The idea is then to redirect the html to it’s associated page in the Flash site (which is doable thanks to deep-linking with SWFAddress). Problem is that google doesnt like ’sneaky’ redirects / doorway pages..

    I’m not sure if this strategy can be made to work. Any ideas?
      • 21395
      • 91 Posts
      You’ve put your finger on the issue: Google doesn’t like anything that looks like a sneaky re-direct - and not only will you not be ranked high, you will almost certainly by ranked deliberately low, and possibly even black-listed altogether.

      As you almost certainly know, (but other readers of this may not, so please excuse this teaching-grandmothers-to-suck-eggs bit), Flash can be nice to look at, but it is anathema if you want anyone to actually find your page via Google - unless you run the flash within an html page that includes basic navigational data to allow the spiders to spider away. Navigation internal to Flash is invisible to text browsers like web spiders. On my own sites, I have had to throw away thousands of dollars-worth of really cool flash design work - money I could ill-afford to spend - because all the navigation was in Flash, and all attempts to serve text using the Flash executable (although we didn’t try your idea) were spurned by Google and other ’bot-masters. We had exactly one link after over a year.

      So I don’t do it any more, and while I use a lot of Flash, when I do it sits inside an html/css page served by Modx. Still cool, but loads of links.
        MODX Revolution 2.6.5-pl (traditional)

        Hosted on MODX Cloud

        Skype: nicbaldeagle
        • 27330
        • 884 Posts
        nice read. I always considered Flash as big NO NO but now I see there is also a way to use it. thanks for posting.
          • 4310
          • 2,310 Posts
          Thanks ganeshXL, I hadn’t thought about using the flash div to contain some sort of SEO friendly alternate content rather than the standard text.